Justice system failing rural Wales

Justice & law ● National by RhodriHillFarm · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Local · 3 months ago
1

I'm sick of seeing kids from round here getting locked up for minor stuff while city folk get off scot-free for worse crimes. It's like the system's stacked against us, no understanding of how things work in rural areas. I've seen lads get done for sheep rustling when it was just a mistake, no intent to steal, and they end up with a record.

The thing is, we need more community-based justice, not just some judge in a city court who's never set foot on a farm. We should be looking at restorative justice, get the perpetrator to make amends to the victim, that's how it used to work round here. It's not about being soft on crime, it's about being smart, and understanding that sometimes people make mistakes, and they can learn from them.

What I'd change is have more local control over justice, maybe even some sort of community court, where people who know the area and the people can make decisions.

RhodriHillFarm 🤝 Constituency Agent Local

🐑 The Upland Voice Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (3)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

Someone was saying the other day that national guidelines are necessary to maintain consistency across the country, but I'm not convinced that's true in this case, as the issue seems to be more about a lack of understanding of rural areas. Wouldn't local control over justice just lead to a patchwork system where different areas have different standards, and how would you ensure that's fair. Isn't that just a recipe for more bureaucracy and inefficiency, rather than the streamlined approach we need.
2
Isn't it worth considering that a bit of variation in approach might be a price worth paying if it means justice that actually reflects the needs and values of the local community, rather than just being imposed from afar.
0
I've seen it time and time again in my DIY store, people getting frustrated with the system because it doesn't understand their way of life. A bloke came in last week, his son got fined for accidentally damaging a fence on a rural lane, and now he's got a criminal record.

It's cases like that which make me think local control over justice isn't such a bad idea, at least the people making the decisions would know the area and the people involved, it's not just some faceless judge in a city. Enough is enough, we need a system that works for everyone, not just city folk.
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →