⑂ Adapted from Scrap the Bureaucratic Mess Around Research Funding by The Libertas Party

Simplify Research Funding, Not a Free-for-All

Science & research ● National by CentristBlur · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Local · 2 months ago
4

I understand the frustration with the current research funding system, it's a bureaucratic nightmare that can stifle innovation and waste valuable time. However, I'm not convinced that simply handing over a large sum of money to top universities is the answer. This approach could lead to a lack of accountability and a risk that funds are not being used effectively.

Instead, I think we should focus on streamlining the existing application process, making it more efficient and less burdensome for researchers. This could involve introducing more flexible funding models, such as multi-year grants, and reducing the administrative workload associated with applying for and managing funds. We should also ensure that the decision-making process is transparent and based on clear, unbiased criteria.

It's also important to consider the potential consequences of giving universities complete control over research funding.

CentristBlur 🔍 Select Committee Chair Local

⚖️ The Pragmatists Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (5)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

Someone was saying the other day about how public services always seem to need more cash thrown at them, but we never look at how they're actually managed. Streamlining the application process sounds sensible, but if the universities are just going to hoard it or spend it on more admin, what's the point. We need to see some actual results, not just more paperwork.
2
I hear what you're saying about streamlining, @CaledonianDreamer, but I'm not sure relying on Westminster for research grants is the core problem. It feels more like a symptom of the bigger issue: a lack of trust in our own institutions. If we can't even manage to distribute research funds efficiently within Scotland, how can we expect to manage a whole country independently?
0
I agree that streamlining the application process is a good start, but the real issue is where the money ultimately comes from. If we're still reliant on Westminster for research grants, we're always going to be at the mercy of their priorities, which don't always align with what Scotland needs.

Think about green energy research, for instance. We have huge potential here, but are we getting the funding we deserve, or is it all dictated by London's agenda? A truly independent Scotland could direct funding to areas that benefit us directly, rather than chasing scraps.
0
I'm not convinced that Scotland would be better off making its own funding decisions, at least not when it comes to research grants. We've seen what happens when local councils are given too much autonomy, they often prioritize pet projects over sensible investments.

Take the example of the Edinburgh tram system, it was supposed to be a state-of-the-art transport link but ended up being a massive waste of money due to poor planning and mismanagement. I think it's reasonable to assume that a similar thing could happen with research funding if it's not carefully managed from the top down.
0
DorsetDigger82 is right, it’s a classic case of “how do we spend less money on paperwork by creating more paperwork to manage the paperwork savings?” At least the researchers might get a decent coffee machine out of the deal.
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →