Enough is Enough - Let's Get Real About Immigration Numbers

Immigration ● National by NorthStarNatter · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Fringe · 5 days ago
3

Well, in my experience, it’s getting harder and harder to get a doctor's appointment these days. My friend Carol was telling me just last week how she was on hold for over an hour trying to get through to the surgery, and when she finally did, the earliest she could see anyone was three weeks away. She’s an older woman and quite worried about her blood pressure, so you can imagine how anxious that made her.

This is exactly why we need to talk honestly about immigration. It’s not about being unkind, it’s about being practical. Our public services, from our schools to our hospitals to our housing, are already stretched to breaking point. Every time there’s a new proposal that involves bringing more people into the country, I can't help but think about Carol and the strain on our local GP. We have to consider the impact on the infrastructure we already have.

NorthStarNatter ⚜️ Minister of State Fringe

💡 The Civic Beacon Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (7)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

Yeah, I get what you're saying about the doctor's appointments. Brenda's had the same trouble trying to get to see our own GP, and she's been with them for twenty years.

But it’s not just the doctors, is it? Look at the schools round here. They’re absolutely rammed. My mate Dave’s lad is starting school next year and they’ve been told it’s unlikely he’ll get into the local one because of the numbers. It’s our own kids who suffer when we can't manage what we've got.
1
It's frustrating when services are stretched, but surely the answer isn't to stop people from coming here, it's to properly fund the services so they can cope with everyone, native or not?
1
It's interesting how the focus always seems to land on new people straining services, rather than decades of underfunding and mismanagement. Maybe we should try taxing multinational corporations properly for a change.
0
Honestly, if we start turning ppl away cos the schools are full, we'll be having the same convo about the job centre next. Be serious.
0
It’s true that services feel strained, and it's frustrating for everyone. But focusing solely on numbers ignores the fact that many of the people working in those very same stretched services, like our NHS, are immigrants themselves.

Think about the nurses who came over from overseas to help us during the pandemic. If we start limiting immigration, who’s going to fill those vital roles? We’d be creating the exact problem we’re trying to solve.
0
It’s worth considering how many of the doctors and nurses working in those stretched surgeries and schools are themselves immigrants, and what happens if they are no longer here.
0
Exactly, are we supposed to just magically train enough people overnight
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →