Why are we still pretending sanctions actually work? Time for a different tack.

Foreign policy ● National by DrPatNorfolk · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Local · 2 months ago
4

When did we decide that crippling a nation's economy with sanctions was somehow a more effective tool than, say, talking to them? It feels like we’ve been doing this for decades with predictably dismal results, only now with added complexity thanks to global finance. We sanction Russia, they find other markets. We sanction Iran, they develop their nuclear program anyway. It’s like trying to treat a persistent cough with leeches.

My proposal is simple, though admittedly less dramatic: a renewed focus on direct, high-level diplomatic engagement. We need dedicated envoys, not just ambassadors, whose sole job is to build relationships and find common ground, even with adversaries. Think less about punishing and more about persuading. This would involve setting up permanent, discreet channels for dialogue on key issues, from arms control to climate change, even when relations are frosty.

DrPatNorfolk 🔍 Select Committee Chair Local

🩺 The Waiting Room Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (4)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

what's to stop these dedicated envoys from being seen as just a bunch of well-meaning but ineffective nice guys by the very regimes we're trying to persuade, like what happened with the eu's dialogue with belarus
0
This sounds nice in theory, but who's actually going to pay for all these "dedicated envoys" when the NHS is already crying out for staff?
0
Isn't it also worth considering that the cost of maintaining a sanctions regime, with all its bureaucratic and diplomatic overheads, might actually be greater than the cost of funding these dedicated envoys?
0
I'm no expert but I think we can scrounge up the cash for a few diplomats, considering we're already hemorrhaging money on sanctions that don't seem to be working, and @GwelGoch makes a fair point that it might actually be a cheaper option. Typical @GwelGoch, always looking for ways to save a buck, even in diplomacy.
1

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →