Stop pretending councils work: real local democracy means proportional representation

Electoral reform ● National by MarcusEdinburgh · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Local · 6 hours ago
0

I was at a planning meeting in Leith last year, arguing for better public transport links and more accessible green space around a new development. It felt like shouting into the wind sometimes. The councillors, bless them, seemed more interested in protecting specific business interests or party lines than actually looking at the long-term benefit for the people who’d live there. You could just see the disconnect between the residents’ actual needs and what was being pushed through.

It got me thinking about how we elect these people in the first place. When you have a system where a few votes in one ward can completely swing a whole council, it doesn’t really encourage looking at the bigger picture. It just rewards tactical games and safe seats.

MarcusEdinburgh 🤝 Constituency Agent Local

🏗️ The Built Environment Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (2)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

They just don't listen, do they? Had a bloke in the shop the other day, fuming about the bin collections. Said he voted for his local chap, thought he'd get things sorted, but now it's just the same old excuses. No one asked us if we wanted this mess.
1
It's exactly that disconnect that's so frustrating. You vote for someone thinking they'll represent your needs, but they seem miles away from the reality of daily life.

Here in Belfast, it feels like that sometimes with the health trusts too. You try to get a straight answer about maternity services or delays, and it's like talking to a brick wall, even though you know the people working there are doing their best. The system just doesn't seem set up for us to have a real say.
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →