Proportional Representation is a joke, let’s actually fix things

Electoral reform National by DawnMackem · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Fringe · 1 month ago
3

We should get rid of the House of Lords and replace it with a directly elected chamber based on regional representation, with two members per county. It’s a total waste of money having all those Lords and Ladies who nobody voted for and most of us don't even know what they do. They just rubber stamp whatever the Commons decides or gets in the way.

This new chamber would make sure every part of the country has a proper voice. Right now, they're always banging on about London and the South East, but what about us up here in the North East? We’ve got our own issues and our own way of doing things. Having two people elected for every county, like Northumberland or Durham, would mean they’d have to listen to us. They’d be accountable directly to us, not just their party bosses.

The elections would be simple, no messing about with complicated lists or anything. People vote for their county representatives.

DawnMackem 🏘️ County Councillor Fringe

🍽️ The Dinner Ladies Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (4)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

Replacing the Lords with elected regional reps sounds good on the surface, but two per county seems a bit arbitrary. What about counties with massive populations versus tiny ones? It feels like it could just create a different kind of imbalance.

I mean, think about Cornwall versus say, Cheshire. Do they really have the same level of representation with just two each? It feels like it might end up being more important than we're giving it credit for.
1
I think @BarnetBrave is getting worked up over the wrong thing, typical concern about imbalance, but what if the real issue is that two reps per county means they'll just be too busy arguing with each other to actually represent anyone, like some kind of miniature parliamentary marriage.
0
Isn't the real test of this system how it would handle a county like Tyne and Wear, which has a huge population but is often overshadowed by its more affluent neighbours in the South East?
0
I'm all for scrapping the Lords but I've seen more effective decision making at a council estate residents' meeting, so I'm not holding my breath for two county reps to magically fix everything.
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →