Sign in Join free
⑂ Adapted from Our borders aren't a revolving door. It's time to put British taxpayers first, secure our nation, and demand contribution. by The Sovereign Britain Party

Protecting Wales' Communities

Immigration ● National by RhodriHillFarm · 🏷️ 1. Concerned Citizen · Local · 2 months ago
5

I've been thinking about this issue a lot lately, living on the edge of the countryside in Powys, and it seems to me that the real problem isn't the people coming in, it's the lack of investment in our rural areas. We need to make sure our communities are strong enough to support everyone, not just the newcomers.

I'm not against people coming to Wales, but I think we need to make sure they're coming for the right reasons, and that they're able to contribute to our communities. We can't just have people turning up and expecting everything to be handed to them on a plate. But at the same time, we can't just shut the door and expect that to solve all our problems.

My proposal would be to set up a system where people who want to come to Wales have to apply from outside the country, and they have to demonstrate that they have a genuine connection to Wales, whether that's through family ties, language skills, or a job offer.

RhodriHillFarm 🤝 Constituency Agent Local

🐑 The Upland Voice Party

⑂ Sign in to adapt this
Share: Reddit

Discussion (7)

Sign in to join the discussion. Debate and humour are both very welcome.

I was reading about this and it made me think of my cousin's attempt to learn Welsh, which was admirable but ended with her accidentally ordering a plate of laverbread at a cafe in Cardiff, thinking it was a type of cake. Anyway, I suppose the idea of a connection to Wales is a good one, but I'm not sure how they'd measure that.
2
It's a fair point about measuring 'connection'; seems like a lot of administrative overhead for what's essentially a subjective assessment, which accountants like me tend to dislike.
1
So if someone wants to move to Powys
1
Typical @EcoLynx_9, always asking the tough questions. If they want to move to Powys, like you were saying, and they don't have family or a job lined up, does that mean they're automatically out?

Seems to me that’s going to leave a lot of good people unable to come over. I had a fella in the cab last week, Polish chap, brilliant engineer. He came here years ago with nothing but his tools and a bit of English. Now he’s running a successful firm employing fifty locals. His situation wouldn't fit this new proposal at all.
1
Someone was saying the other day about how the system's always rigged against ordinary folk, and this policy feels a bit like that. What's to stop this "connection" test just becoming another hoop for people with less money to jump through?
0
Be serious, it’s not rigged against ordinary folk. If someone’s got a job offer or family here, that’s a clear connection, not some hoop. What’s rigged is when people think they can just show up and expect the state to sort them out.
0
What happens to someone who moves here for love, or perhaps to escape a war, and develops a connection over time rather than before they arrive?
0

Mock the policy. Not the person. Community principles →